How Do You Measure Success in Digital? Five Metrics for CEOs

Executive Overview

McKinsey’s core message is that CEOs should not measure digital transformation by the number of initiatives underway. A long list of platforms, apps, pilots, infrastructure projects, and analytics efforts does not necessarily prove that digital is improving revenue, profitability, market share, efficiency, or competitive advantage.

Instead, CEOs need a small set of cross-enterprise metrics that connect digital activity to business value. The article argues that the CEO is uniquely positioned to see across functions and regions, prioritize a focused digital roadmap, and ensure digital investments produce measurable performance gains.

Major Takeaways for Business Leaders

1. Start with a digital roadmap, not a basket of projects

McKinsey warns that one common failure mode in digital strategy is approving too many disconnected projects. CEOs should push the organization to prioritize three to five bold digital initiatives that can materially improve company performance, rather than spreading resources thinly across every attractive idea.

2. Measure return on digital investment

The first CEO metric is return on digital investments. Leaders should assess not only whether individual initiatives are producing value, but also whether the portfolio of digital investments supports the organization’s strategic goals. McKinsey recommends transforming one business domain at a time—such as a customer journey, function, or critical process—so the company can reuse data, technology, teams, and workflows across related use cases.

3. Track how much technology budget funds bold digital initiatives

The second metric is the percentage of annual technology budget spent on bold digital initiatives. McKinsey argues that companies spending too much of their technology budget on maintenance and infrastructure may struggle to generate digital-driven growth. In banking, for example, the article notes that many institutions spend about 92 percent of digital budgets on infrastructure and maintenance, leaving only 8 percent for business-improvement initiatives.

4. Measure speed to build and deploy digital applications

The third metric is the time required to build a digital application. McKinsey emphasizes that CEOs should track cycle time to market, not merely time to proof of concept. The article suggests that analytics models should reach field use in less than four months, while software applications such as frontline dashboards should reach users in less than six months.

5. Link leader incentives to value-creating digital builds

The fourth metric is the percentage of business leaders’ incentives linked to value-creating digital builds. McKinsey argues that digital transformation requires accountability beyond the technology function. Business leaders, technology leaders, and especially the CTO should be incentivized around value creation, speed, adoption, and successful builds—not simply infrastructure reliability or project activity.

6. Monitor whether the company is attracting, promoting, and retaining top technical talent

The fifth metric is top technical talent attracted, promoted, and retained. McKinsey describes technical talent as one of the most important drivers of long-term digital success, including expertise in data engineering, analytics, design, user experience, and core technology. The article also emphasizes talent integration: technical talent should work side by side with the business, not sit in an isolated technology silo.

Talking Points for Executive Teams

Digital success should be measured by business outcomes, not by the number of initiatives launched.

The CEO’s role is to create focus. A clear digital roadmap with a few bold priorities is more valuable than a broad portfolio of disconnected efforts.

Return on digital investment depends on adoption. Insights and tools only create value when employees change workflows and use them in real decisions.

Technology budget allocation reveals strategic intent. A company that spends most of its technology budget maintaining legacy systems may not be investing enough in growth, differentiation, or customer experience.

Speed matters. Long development cycles can cause digital products to become outdated before they ever reach the front line.

Incentives shape behavior. If leaders are not rewarded for digital value creation, speed, and adoption, digital transformation may remain a side project.

Technical talent must be embedded in the business. The goal is not just to hire more digital specialists, but to integrate them into agile teams that solve high-value business problems.

Reflection Questions for Leaders

1. Are we measuring digital transformation by activity or by measurable business value?
2. Do we have three to five bold digital priorities, or are we funding too many disconnected initiatives?
3. Which business domain should we transform first to create visible, scalable value?
4. How much of our technology budget goes toward growth and business improvement versus maintenance and infrastructure?
5. How long does it take us to move from idea to a digital product that employees or customers actually use?
6. Are business leaders accountable for digital outcomes, or is digital still treated mainly as a technology-function responsibility?
7. Do we have enough technical talent embedded in agile teams alongside business leaders?
8. Are we investing enough in adoption, workflow redesign, and change management to turn digital tools into business results?

Potential Action Items

Create or refresh a CEO-level digital scorecard using McKinsey’s five metrics: return on digital investments, technology budget allocation, application build time, incentive alignment, and technical talent strength.

Audit all digital initiatives and classify them as either bold, value-creating priorities or lower-impact activity.

Narrow the digital roadmap to three to five initiatives with clear business ownership, expected value, adoption requirements, and milestones.

Choose one high-value business domain—such as customer acquisition, pricing, retention, supply chain, or employee experience—and transform it end to end.

Review technology budget allocation to determine whether enough investment is going toward growth, innovation, customer experience, and efficiency.

Measure cycle time from idea to field deployment, and distinguish between proof-of-concept activity and tools that are actually used.

Link executive incentives to digital adoption, value delivered, speed of delivery, and successful scaling.

Assess whether technical talent is embedded in business teams and whether the company is retaining the builders, designers, engineers, and data specialists required for long-term success.

Recommended Similar Articles

The COVID-19 recovery will be digital: A plan for the first 90 days
Recommended for leaders looking for a practical digital recovery and acceleration agenda.

Digital strategy in a time of crisis
Useful for CEOs and executive teams reassessing digital priorities under volatile business conditions.

The drumbeat of digital: How winning teams play
A helpful companion piece for understanding how high-performing digital teams operate and sustain momentum.